A man I know slipped on a wet floor at a grocery store in Houston. Fell hard, fractured his wrist, missed six weeks of work. He called an attorney the next day expecting to hear that he had a strong case.
The attorney asked him three questions. Was there a wet floor sign? He wasn’t sure. Had he been there before and knew the floor got slippery near the produce section? He admitted he had. Was there any video of the fall? He didn’t know.
The attorney took the case but told him honestly it wasn’t as straightforward as it looked. The uncertainty around the sign and his prior knowledge of the condition were going to be arguments the defense used.
He was genuinely hurt. He had real losses. Whether he had a viable personal injury lawsuit came down to specific legal elements that most injured people don’t think about until an attorney starts asking the uncomfortable questions.
The Four Things Every Case Needs
Personal injury law is built on negligence. To have grounds for a lawsuit, four elements need to be present and provable. All four.
Duty. The person or entity that hurt you had a legal obligation to act with reasonable care toward you. Drivers have a duty to operate vehicles safely. Property owners have a duty to maintain reasonably safe conditions for visitors. Doctors have a duty to meet the standard of care in their field. This element is rarely the hard part.
Breach. They failed to meet that duty. The driver ran a red light. The property owner knew about the wet floor and didn’t fix it or warn anyone. The doctor missed a diagnosis that a reasonably competent physician would have caught. Breach requires proof, not just assertion. What documentation exists? What witnesses saw what happened? What records show the defendant knew about a dangerous condition?
Causation. Their breach caused your specific injury. This is where defense attorneys fight hardest, particularly in cases with significant damages. If you had a prior back injury and you’re claiming a back injury from the accident, the defense argues your current condition predates the crash. If you slipped on a wet floor but also have balance issues from a pre-existing condition, the defense argues the fall was partly your own doing. Causation has to be established clearly, with medical evidence that connects the specific injury to the specific event.
Damages. You suffered real, documentable losses. Medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, permanent limitations. A case where all three prior elements are present but the damages are minimal may not be economically viable to pursue even if everything else is technically there.
Justia’s personal injury law resources cover these elements in detail, including how negligence gets proven in different types of cases and what damages are recoverable under various circumstances. Reading through this before your first attorney consultation means you’re not hearing these concepts for the first time when it matters.
Having a legitimate injury doesn’t automatically mean you have a viable lawsuit.
People get hurt every day in ways that are genuinely unfortunate but don’t involve anyone else’s negligence. You trip on a crack in your own driveway. You slip on a wet floor that had a clearly visible warning sign. You’re in a car accident that was entirely your fault. Real injury, no viable claim.
The question isn’t whether you were hurt. It’s whether someone else’s failure to meet a legal duty caused your injury. Those two things feel related but they’re separate inquiries and the answer to one doesn’t determine the answer to the other.
Texas-Specific Rules That Affect Your Case
Texas uses modified comparative fault with a 51% bar. If you’re found 51% or more responsible for the accident that caused your injury, you recover nothing. If you’re found 30% responsible, you recover 70% of your damages.
Insurance adjusters and defense attorneys use this rule aggressively. Every percentage point of fault they assign to you directly reduces what they owe. The man from the grocery store who admitted he knew the floor got slippery near the produce section had just given the defense a head start on a comparative fault argument.
Texas also has a two-year statute of limitations for most personal injury claims. Two years from the date of injury to file a lawsuit. Miss it and the claim is gone regardless of how strong it was. Claims involving government entities have shorter notice requirements, sometimes as little as six months.
These rules create real practical consequences. A case that looks viable in month three can be much harder in month twenty. Starting the process early protects options that don’t stay open indefinitely.
The Cases That Look Strong But Aren’t
Liability seems clear but the damages are minimal. You have a provable case but the medical treatment was limited, you missed no work, and the injury resolved completely in two weeks. The claim technically exists but pursuing it through litigation costs more than you’d recover. Many attorneys will pass on these cases not because you weren’t wronged but because the economics don’t support the work required.
Liability is disputed in ways that are genuinely hard to resolve. Two drivers who both claim they had the light. A fall in a location with no camera coverage and no witnesses. An injury at a party where a dozen people saw different things. Cases like these can be pursued but they require honest assessment of how a jury is likely to resolve the factual dispute.
The defendant has no meaningful ability to pay. A viable case against someone with no insurance and no assets produces a judgment you can’t collect. Your attorney needs to identify all available insurance coverage and any viable defendants with resources before case viability is fully assessed.
Pre-existing conditions that complicate causation. You had a prior back problem and now have a worse back problem. The injury is real. The causation is contested. These cases can be won with the right medical expert testimony but they require more work and carry more risk than cases without that complication.
The Cases That Look Weak But Might Not Be
The vehicle damage was minimal. Low-speed rear-end collisions with minor property damage produce serious cervical spine injuries regularly. Research on crash biomechanics shows that occupant injury and vehicle damage are poorly correlated at low speeds. An attorney who dismisses a case because the car wasn’t badly damaged is making a mistake.
The plaintiff contributed to the accident. Texas’s comparative fault system doesn’t bar recovery unless you’re 51% or more at fault. A case where you were 30% responsible still has a viable claim for 70% of your damages. The question isn’t whether you contributed at all. It’s how much.
The defendant claims there was no notice of the dangerous condition. Property owners often deny knowledge of hazards. Maintenance logs, prior incident reports, and communication records sometimes tell a different story. These records have to be obtained before they disappear.
What Makes a Case Stronger
Documentation built immediately after the incident.
Photographs of the scene, the conditions that caused the injury, and your visible injuries taken the same day carry more weight than descriptions provided months later. Witnesses identified and contacted while they’re still accessible and while their memories are fresh. Medical care sought the same day, creating a record that establishes both the timeline and the connection between the incident and the injury.
A daily journal started immediately after the injury. Pain levels, functional limitations, specific things you couldn’t do that you normally would. This documentation supports non-economic damages that have no other fixed source of evidence.
Consistent medical treatment that follows the treating physician’s recommendations. Gaps in treatment give the defense a mitigation argument. Stopping physical therapy before your doctor recommends it because you feel better creates an opening the insurer will use.
If you’re genuinely unsure whether what happened to you supports a viable lawsuit, get a professional evaluation. Not a Google search. Not a friend who had a case once. An attorney who does this work and will tell you honestly what the assessment is.
Haque Law handles personal injury cases in Houston and across Texas and understands specifically how to evaluate the strength of a claim under Texas law, what the realistic range of outcomes looks like, and whether the specific facts of your situation support pursuing a case. You can review the Super Lawyers profile for background on the firm’s recognition and practice areas before reaching out.
Most personal injury attorneys work on contingency. Nothing upfront. The consultation that tells you whether you have a viable case costs you nothing.
The man from the grocery store eventually settled. The disputed warning sign and his prior knowledge of the floor condition didn’t end his case. They complicated it. His attorney built around those complications with surveillance footage that showed other customers slipping in the same area that week, evidence the store had notice of the recurring problem regardless of whether a sign was present that day.
The case he thought was straightforward wasn’t. The case he almost didn’t pursue because of those complications was worth pursuing. Neither of those things was obvious going in.
That’s why the evaluation matters. What you can see from the outside isn’t always what’s actually there.